Someone showed me the new mayor of New York, Mamdani, posting about his city’s preparedness for snow, and how amazingly serious they take the sanitation there. They have fancy uniforms and everything! I thought, hey, I bet we have something similar at home, having a world-class city here. Well, it’s not as fancy, no shiny uniforms or swearing-in ceremonies, but it seems alright. Its a pretty and clean city, for one of Canada’s major cities.
I thought, What’s our biggest city’s public services like? “Under Mayor Rob Ford the City began to look at ways to cut cost on waste management.” Well, I have no evidence to this, but I’m sure if I flew over there and interviewed people about the quality of city services before and after Ford was mayor, I’d hear the same story as ever, It got worse over time.
If you ask your parents or grandparents about public services, they will almost always claim “things were better back then”. They are right. There was a point in time, pretty much after the second world war that there was widespread and high quality services here in north america. Our bloody politicians have been selling off our infrastructure and services for damn near a century, at best to offset the slow lowering of tax rates applied to the top 10%, and at worst to simply line the pockets of them and their friends. Although the first option ends up in the hands of their friends either way. If you point the camera in the right direction, it sure looks like slow-motion looting.
The lie they tell us is always the same, that service quality will remain the same, and nothing will change. This is incredibly stupid when inspected through the thinnest lens of logic. There is no way for a service to be organized in a way for it to financially compete with a well run public service, when an owner wants to take profit from the service. Secondly, any attempt to reach the most efficient point through aggressive competition leads to confusion and instability, as an extremely competitive field is practically a battlefield. These are not things you want to worry about when talking about the clean water you drink, or the removal of the shit from the pipes under our feet.
The most fulfilling system for our critical services will always be a single, public owned service with solid checks and balances to prevent problems. All services are paid for, and public owned services are paid for by a form of crowdfunding called taxes, and private owned services are are usually paid for directly by individuals or by our municipalities contracting out. After all, a public owned service is owned by us, and what we get out of it is the service, and whats the point of private ownership if your not taking money out of your company to enrich yourself?
As an afterthought, if you pay attention to the people arguing that the publicly owned services are bad, and would be better if privately owned, its always the people that want to buy them, or the politicians that want to sell them. Weird how they are the ones that would benefit from the arrangement, eh?